The paper deals with the concept of the separate legal entity of a corporation. The importance of this doctrine and its relevance in the analysis of laws relating to companies is evident in the case of salomon v a salomon and co ltd 1897 ac22, the leading case which gave effect to the separate entity principle macintyre 2012. If people choose to conduct their affairs through the medium of corporations, they are taking advantage of the fact that in law those corporations are separate legal entities, whose property and actions are in law not the property or actions of their incorporators or controlling shareholders. In one study, the rate of lifetime depression among childhood rape survivors was 52% compared to 27% among nonvictims saunders et al. Thus the need for this exposition on the jurisprudence of the concept of separate legal personality. The consequences of a corporate personality law company. The mythology of salomons case and the law dealing with the tort liabilities of corporate groups. When a company is formed by registering under the companies act 1985, it becomes a corporation with different characteristics from that of a partnership or other unincorporated body. The doctrine of the separate legal entity 86 words bartleby. Separate legal personality is a consequence of incorporation under the corporate law regime. The concept of legal personality was discussed in chapter 4.
The doctrine of separate legal personality laid down in salomons case has received increased recognition and is often cited in court today. The concept of separate legal entity is 500 years old and it means that the corporation is separate in all spheres of its activities. Consequences of incorporation separate legal personality a company is liable for its own debts the shareholders are not liable for the debts and. As a person separated from its members, it is the company that conducts its business, owns its. Certainly, most textbooks contain chapters on international personality or on the subjects of international law, the two expressions mostly used as synonyms. Moreover, another example that shows a company as a separate legal personality it is related to the companys property. The consequences of treating the company as a person from its participants include the following. Separate legal personality 15 separate legal personality a company is a legal entity in its own right separate from its shareholders and continues in existence until. A critical analysis of the piercing of the corporate veil. The separate legal personality of a company, as aforementioned, represents one of the most fundamental principle of company law. The doctrine of separate legal entity is a doctrine which has gained increasing importance in the analysis of company law. In fact, while the company legal relationships until that time had been principally based on transactions and activities between natural or real persons, namely human beings, from.
In this paper we explore on the following statement made by lord halsbury l. Another consequence of this doctrine is that a companys property is its own, hence neither. Moreover, it is not possible to treat all the nonstate actors as a homogenous. The separate legal personality concept is useful in large companies where there are many shareholders, and these shareholders are frequently changing. Separate legal personality of a company law essays. The psychological consequences of sexual trauma march 2006 page 3 of 11 lie esearch survivors are also more likely to suffer from depression, suicide, and other mental health problems. Mr salomon had a business selling boots and at one point he made it into a company with his 6 family members making up the other shareholders 7 was a minimum in those days. One of the most important modern consequences of the decision in salomon, and its. This means that a legal personality is not a natural phenomenon but a creature of law. It seems likely that it will be applied where, as in the airport cold storage case, the individuals in question fail to respect the separate legal personality of their company or else try to exploit its separate legal existence in an unscrupulous and unconscionable way as the individuals did in that case by treating it as legal entity when. One of the most important modern consequences of the decision in salomon. The consequences of this separate legal personality are several. Mar 12, 2014 under the concept of separate legal entity 1. The doctrine of separate legal personality, as embodied in.
Under the concept of separate legal entity, a company will becomes a body corporate that exists separately with its owner and distinct from its individual members and directors. Concept of separate legal entity and consequences of. This chapter discusses the separate legal personality of companies, covering. In general terms, a company, because it is a corporation, is a person in law separate from any and all of the individuals involved in the company whether those individuals are its ownersshareholders, its managersdirectors or. The term company, in its general sense, can be defined as a group of persons, associated together to achieve some common objective.
Further effects of a company possessing separate legal personality, include. A critical analysis of the piercing of the corporate veil in. The consequences of this separate legal personality were elucidated by lord davey who postulated that as a separate entity a company has the. The fact that the concept of separate legal entity has often been formulated only in the most general terms may have very undesir able consequences. The various theories of legal personality are also discussed. When a company is registered it is clothed in a legal personality and has almost the same rights and powers as a human being.
An historical perspective 455 controversy across several countries, and the ongoing economic and social issues with which the legal position is associated, remains a highly relevant concern. In others word, the corporation is an entity just like human being created using legal and official purpose. Where a company incurs a contractual obligation or a liability in tort, that obligation or liability is the companys and not an obligation or. If the company does not have a separate legal personality, it would mean that a change among the shareholders would require a transfer of the companys assets. The decision made by the house of lords in salomons case confirms gooleys observations that the doctrine of separate legal personality was a doubleedged sword puig 2000.
The law, in creating legal persons, always does so by personifying. Advantages and disadvantages of incorporation of a company. Legal personality, being an artificial creation of the law, may be conferred on entities other individual human beings. A major implication of the act is the doctrine of the separate legal entity. Section 1241 of the corporate act 2001 says a company has the legal capacity and powers of an individual both in and outside this jurisdiction. If a business is a separate legal entity, it means it has some of the same rights in law as a person. Salomon v salomon 2 identified that a company is not only an association of its members, but also a person separate from its members which is extremely significant as it carries many consequences. Although the operation of the separate legal entity and limited liability. Nov 06, 2011 discuss the concept of separate legal entity and consequences of corporate personality on a company. Discuss the concept of separate legal entity and consequences of corporate personality on a company.
This chapter deals with the legal personality of a company which is separate from its members, capable of owning property, entering into contracts and being a party to legal proceedings. Jul, 2010 the separate legal personality concept is useful in large companies where there are many shareholders, and these shareholders are frequently changing. The separate legal entity concept law company business partnership essay. Principle of separate legal personality separate legal personality. Separate legal personality 15 separate legal personality a company is a legal entity in its own right separate from its shareholders and continues in existence until it is removed from the new zealand register. In fact, also in this case it is the company which owns its property, not the members. The legal personality of other subjects and its consequences give raise to doubts and disputes. Separate personality and limited liability are cornerstones. Limited liability and separate legal personality are arguably the most important. Normally legal personality is granted by law to all human beings.
Significance of corporate personality and the meaning of lifting the veil of incorporation. The idea of a company is that it has a separate legal personality to its members or directors. Lipton, phillip the mythology of salomons case and the law. Titles in the casebook on series provide readers with a comprehensive selection of case law extracts for their studies.
I am quite satisfied that the indiscriminate use of. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. This is referred to as a separate legal personality. First, as a separate legal person, a registered company is capable of suing and being sued. Some seven men form an association if possible, all. A separate legal entity may be set up in the case of a corporation or a limited liability company, to separate the actions of the entity from those of the individual or other company.
The case of salomon v salomon established the separate legal entity doctrine. Extracts have been chosen from a wide range of historical and contemporary cases to illustrate the reasoning processes of the courts and to show how legal principles are developed. Jul 05, 2019 explain how the concepts of separate legal personality and limited liability give rise to the circumstances gilbert and sullivan describe. With reference to case law discuss the meaning and effect of separate legal personality. This date marks a quasi copernican revolution of the entire uk system of company law. This means that most of the legal entity in business is separate from another business or individual with value to accountability. A brief overview of the separate legal personality of a company and its consequences. Yet, although this is a fundamental concept, it has proved extremely intractable to define and to describe satisfactorily. Start studying consequences of incorporation separate legal personality.
This is the fundamental attribute of corporate personality, from which all the other practical consequences flow. Because of the said concept of separate legal personality, one of the main advantages corporations enjoy is limited liability. A company is a body corporate and is capable of exercising all the functions of an incorporated company. Do you think that the law goes far enough in disregarding, or avoiding the consequences of, separate legal personality, when justice requires it to do so.
Since 1897, the principle of the separate legal personality of a company has become a vital part of company law. Artificial personality, juridical personality, or juristic personality is the characteristic of a nonliving entity regarded by law to have the status of personhood a juridical or artificial person latin. The consequences of a corporate personality law company business partnership essay. Recognition and international legal personality of nonstate actors1. Juristic or legal person is one to which law attributes legal personality. In this project, we have attempted to study and analyze the concept of separate legal entity, the various grounds for piercing of the corporate veil and elements of lifting of corporate veil analyzed through the lens of leading case laws and judgements. It has been the underlying cause of the use of nomenclature such as that quoted above, concerning which younger l. As there is no involvement of the shareholder, limited liability negates any debt, contractual obligation, or any form of accountability for any wrongful act or liability on the part. Nov, 2012 the doctrine of separate legal personality continues to be of paramount importance to english company law, although arguably the doctrine may have lost some of its importance due to the number of exceptions that have arisen. A companys obligation and liabilities are its own, and not those of its participants. Recognition and international legal personality of non. In essence humanity is a state of nature and legal personality is an artificial construct which may or may not be conferred.
Recognition and international legal personality of non state. In this article, cheshta jetly pursuing diploma in entrepreneurship administration and business laws from nujs, kolkata, discusses advantages and disadvantages of incorporation of a company. Consequences of incorporation separate legal personality. In other words, the corporation is a legal entity distinct from its members. Jan 30, 2015 the paper deals with the concept of the separate legal entity of a corporation. However, one of the most coveted benefits to be gained from the formation of a company relates to the concept of the company as a legal person separate from its members. The company is a independent person in law and not a trustee or agent. Separate legal personality of a company law teacher. Separate legal personality of a company law essays essay. Consequences of treating the company as a separate legal entity. Consequences of treating the company as a separate legal. The concept is looked at form the point of view of the origin of the separate identity of a corporation and the need for such a distinction along with the capacity and liability of a corporation. The company was thus a separate legal entity and there is a corporate veil between it and its shareholders they are limited in liability and salomon could not be pursued personally for the debts of the companies. Separate legal personality of a company lawteacher.
The doctrine of the separate legal entity 86 words. The concept of the company as a separate legal person, a metaphor of limited use like all legal fictions, can only be justified by and assessed to the extent that it serves the laws social and. There are a few consequences incurred based on the independent legal entity theory. The principle was first accepted in salomon v salomon, a landmark case which is often considered to have established one of the most important principles within. It is separate from its owner, from its employees and due to this separation between the corporation and an individual the shareholders liability is also limited. The nexus between corporate personality and limited liability. Concept developed in company law, relating to the legal status between a company limited by shares and its owners. The effect of incorporation doctrine of separate legal entity the company and its members are two separate distinct entities salomon lwn. It considers the case salomon v a salomon and co ltd 1897 ac 22, in which the house of lords affirmed separate corporate personality by rejecting attempts, on behalf of creditors, to impose liability for a. Thus, as showed for the business, the members cannot claim interests on the companys property. The separate legal entity concept law company business. Though, the doctrine of separate legal entity has been argued as a double edged sword. Pulling back the curtains separate legal personality and. The consequences of a corporate personality have significant affects for corporations and its members.
680 406 337 733 1201 929 1257 225 491 244 1356 1611 1300 176 57 1105 1290 1349 1041 712 1044 1460 1101 438 324 868 1552 741 1529 470 1644 964 1295 1459 1248 565 170 1552 731 1248 326 974 279 1313 1438 895 527 1361